All issues
    October 31, 20263 min read

    Teach People How to Disagree Sideways

    Photograph illustrating Teach People How to Disagree Sideways
    All polishing is done by friction.
    Mary Parker Follett

    Give Peer Disagreement A Better Route

    Two colleagues disagree about how to serve a customer. One wants to customize the offer; the other wants to protect a consistent service model. Neither is behaving badly. Yet their disagreement soon becomes a story about character: “She never follows the process.” “He cares more about rules than customers.” The work slows, allies are recruited, and an ordinary difference becomes a lasting division.

    Intentional culture design includes deciding how people will work through friction with peers. It is not enough to encourage kindness or tell everyone to be professional. Those instructions offer little guidance when two reasonable people need different things. A lasting culture gives them a practical route from competing positions to a workable agreement.

    Management thinker Mary Parker Follett explored this possibility in her essay “Constructive Conflict.” Rather than treating every conflict as something one side must win, she advocated integration: looking beneath opposing demands for interests that a better solution might accommodate. Her observation, “All polishing is done by friction,” invites a useful question: What could this disagreement improve if we handled it deliberately?

    Separate Positions From Needs

    Start by separating positions from needs. “No customization” is a position. “We need a service we can deliver reliably with our current staffing” describes an underlying need. “Customize everything” is another position. “This customer cannot use our standard format” reveals a different need. Once the needs are visible, the conversation has more room. Perhaps the team can offer one alternative format without redesigning the entire service.

    Give colleagues a simple conversation structure before they need it. Each person describes the observable issue, its effect on the work, and the need they are trying to protect. The other person summarizes what they heard before offering their own account. This is not a requirement to agree. It is a check against solving a caricature of the other person's concern.

    Build Options And Set Boundaries

    Next, ask both people to generate options together before choosing one. Avoid making the first speaker's proposal the default that everyone else must attack or defend. Put at least three possible approaches on paper, including their costs and limitations. Sometimes integration is possible. Sometimes a genuine tradeoff remains. Either way, the decision becomes less personal when the alternatives and consequences are visible.

    Managers have a design role here, but they should not become the automatic referee for every difference. When a peer disagreement reaches them, they can first ask whether the colleagues have compared needs and explored options. If not, they can facilitate that conversation. If the disagreement requires a resource decision beyond either person's remit, the manager should make that decision rather than sending them back to negotiate something they cannot resolve.

    There must also be clear limits. Harassment, discrimination, threats, and retaliation are not ordinary differences to be settled through mutual accommodation. People need safe reporting routes and appropriate investigation. Nobody should have to negotiate basic dignity with someone who is harming them. A constructive conflict practice distinguishes legitimate disagreement from conduct that requires protection and accountability.

    Create A Practical Disagreement Guide

    This week's practical takeaway is to create a one-page peer disagreement guide with three prompts: What happened? What does each person need to protect? What options could address those needs? Add a clear route for unresolved tradeoffs and a separate route for misconduct. Practice with a fictional work scenario before using it in a live dispute. Culture becomes sturdier when disagreement no longer requires either silence or a winner.

    Tips for building lasting culture

    1. 1

      Draft a peer disagreement guide that separates observable facts, underlying needs, possible solutions, and escalation routes.

    2. 2

      In your next peer disagreement, summarize the other person's need and ask whether you understood it before proposing a solution.

    3. 3

      Use a fictional customer-service dispute to practice generating three options that address both colleagues' concerns.

    Never miss an issue

    A new quote, article, and set of tips every Saturday morning.

    Browse the full archive